11/16/2004

The Death of Arafat


Arafat's death has come at an interesting point considering the policies of Israel and the United States. George W. Bush, the first US president to mention the two state solution in a formal speech, has been eager to make peace a possibility between the Israelis and the Palestinians. However, Bush is also the first president to validate the Israeli settlements in the West Bank which he articulated as the rightful land of the Israelis. One of the motivations behind Bush's and possibly Sharon's thinking is to create two portions of a Palestinian state that will ultimately fail, giving the Israeli government the upperhand to annex the territory for good. This in my opinion will ultimately be the only answer, not through the Israeli annexation method I described above, but the actual creation of a binational state that embraces the Palestinians and the Israelis. There is no way that the two groups can live independent and separate lives when they have historically worked together as intertwined communities. This conflict began in the 20th century when political zionism was created by Theodore Hertzl. Keep in mind the key word attached to zionism...POLITICAL. Most people who argue the conflict or at least the many people I have encountered rarely know anything about the Zionist movement and believe the word was created by Arabs who hate the Jews because of their exceptional status in the Bible, or the exact words from God. This is the breaking point for me when it comes to political discussions because of the complexities surrounding the issue, and once these points are made, the discussion usually turns into a history lesson, one that I am tired of giving. So the next question I ask myself is why are most Americans uneducated when it comes to the conflict itself??? Is it because they rely on 15 minute reports by mainstream American media??? Or do they form their opinions from reports of suicide bombings that took place in Israel and never hear of the daily deaths of Palestinians in the occupied territories? Lets just say that I am left puzzled everyday by the different arguments that I have encountered. As this forum is supposed to be dedicated to my trip in Lebanon, I am still interested in Middle Eastern events and this one happens to weigh heavily on most of the conflicts in the Middle East.
Now back to Arafat and his death, it will be interesting to see how Palestinians will restructure the Palestinian Authority (PA) in hopes of finding a credible successor. There has already been some internal struggle as former PM Abu Mazen was attacked while visiting some mourners in a tent after Arafat's burial service. The assailant shouted out that he is an agent for the Americans. These extreme parties spearheaded by HAMAS and ISLAMIC JIHAD need to be incorporated somehow into the government and done so delicately that more moderate elements will flourish within the organizations. The Hizb Allah can be seen as a model for this type of incorporation, or parliamentization. Hizb Allah, which has become more moderate these days, except in its fight against Israel, which people have to understand is provoked by Israel daily, has 7 members in parliament 1 of whom is Maronite Christian and 1 who is Sunni Muslim. The party does not require an ethnic identity to be a member, for the group was created to resist the Israeli occupation. This incorporation will prove to be a extremely crucial step to move towards peace.

A Reflection on Arafat

While Arafat will also be branded by the American media as a conniving terrorist who was never working for peace, the Palestinians will always remember him for be a strong willed leader who would not give up the cause of the Palestinian people. There are many different issues that Arafat held as important to the Palestinian people which included the right to return, a right that seemingly will never be granted to the Palestinians. Some of the conditions that were demanded by the Israelis, would mean defeat to Arafat and the Palestinian people, so while Americans and Westerners alike look at different offers Arafat was given and think rationally that Arafat was crazy to not accept what Israel was offering, they need to turn the table and see it as what the Palestinians have already given up. Putting aside ones religious belief, such as the issue of Israel belonging to the Jews because of God (Allah), the Palestinians have been making the most concessions out of the two parties. Just as a last comment, I want to remind anyone reading this, whether it be a friend of mine or not, that I am in no way inclined to one side or the other, while I am interested in Arab studies, I am a white American with a Catholic background. I have studied the Bible very well. I am talking a rational human being who are looking at two separate parties in conflict.

Solution to the Conflict?

I have said once before that the only true solution is the binational state, which may not be the most immediate step in the peace process, (look at it as a phase such as Marx's thinking of capitalism) the phase being the two state solution first. Finally, the binational state will take root after the two parties are willing to drop the violence and Israel becomes demilitarized. The United States will have to be a major player in pressuring the Israelis to give concessions to the Palestinians, or the conflict will remain with asymetric power distribution. Only time will tell.

Well that is enough for now, hope you have enjoyed this discussion, and it will generate a thirst in your mouth for more information.

11/08/2004


This is a village in Syria between two mountains.
American in Beirut

This is my first blog

Here is my first blog, it feels so amazing that I will have the ability to publish my own thoughts, feelings, emotions, opinions, and share it with all of the world.......if there is anyone out there that is interested. Well I created this page so I will be able to keep everyone up to date with what i have been up to as well as post images so y'all can have a chance to see Lebanon as well, through my lens, that is....Well, that is all for now, currently I am working on planning my internship, and have a lot I need to prepare before this trip becomes a reality.

Bye for now,
John

A mural I found when I climbed into a deserted and destroyed building in Hamra
American in Beirut